116 Oakes Rd, Old Toongabbie, NSW, 2146 - 0401 935 643

To Claim or Not to Claim: Navigating Car Repair Decisions After an Accident​

After experiencing a car accident, one of the pivotal decisions vehicle owners face is whether to file an insurance claim for repairs or pay out of pocket. This choice often hinges on a thorough understanding of the costs involved and the potential impact on insurance premiums, especially for owners who value maintaining their car’s perfection. Let’s delve into the critical considerations that should guide this decision-making process.

Understanding Repair Costs: The First Step

Before deciding on the route to take, the initial step is obtaining a private quote for the repairs. Imagine discovering a significant dent on your car’s bonnet and needing to assess whether to file a claim. The cost of repair is the determinant factor here. For instance, if the quote comes in at $2,500 but your insurance excess is $850, filing a claim is a financially sound decision. On the contrary, if a repair quote is lower than your excess, say $650 versus an $850 excess, it’s more economical to handle the expense privately.

Evaluating the Impact on No Claim Bonuses

Many vehicle owners are rightfully concerned about the implications of filing a claim on their no claim bonus (NCB). Insurance premiums are an ongoing expense, often increasing over time, and the advantage of having a no claim bonus is a significant reduction in these costs. The dilemma arises when you face a repair scenario; should the potential loss of your NCB deter you from making a claim?

The reality is, insurance exists to protect you from significant financial burdens following accidents. If the economics of making a claim outweigh the costs of private repairs — even considering the potential impact on your no claim bonus — then it’s advisable to proceed with the claim. It’s essential, however, to carefully weigh the immediate financial benefits against the long-term costs of increased premiums.

Making the Informed Choice

The decision to file an insurance claim or pay for repairs out of pocket should be informed by a clear understanding of the costs involved and a strategic evaluation of your insurance policy’s benefits.

Here are a few steps to guide you:

Get a Detailed Repair Quote: Always start with a precise assessment of the damage and a quote for the repairs needed. This gives you a baseline for comparison.

Assess Your Insurance Policy: Understand your excess, the current status of your no claim bonus, and how a claim might affect your premiums in the future.

Consider the Long-Term Impact: Evaluate the potential increase in insurance premiums against the cost of not claiming and losing your no claim bonus.

Make an Informed Decision: If the cost of repairs significantly exceeds your excess and you can justify the claim’s impact on your insurance policy, it’s prudent to file a claim. Conversely, for minor repairs that cost less than or marginally above your excess, paying privately might be the better option.